Skip to content

www.la3dclub.com

Los Angeles 3-D Club (SCSC)

cropped-SCSC-Logo_l-1.jpg
Primary Menu
  • Calendar
  • Galleries
    • 3-D Movies
    • 3-D Photos
      • Ray Zone
  • Membership
    • 3-D News
    • Join The LA 3-D Club
  • About Us
    • Officers/Contact
    • History
    • Our Venues
  • Meetings
    • Virtual Meeting Videos
  • Articles and Links
    • Club Member Biographies and Interviews
    • Historical 3D Articles
    • Knowledge Base and Stereoscopic How-to
      • Fuji W1/W3 Camera
      • Hasbro My3D/Iphone/Ipod
    • LA 3-D Club on Facebook
    • News Archive
    • Reviews
      • 3-D Book Reviews
      • 3-D Movie Reviews
      • 3-D Product Reviews
    • Resources/Links
  • Competitions
    • Club Competition Uploader
    • PSA Hollywood Exhibition 2024
    • Rules for Club Competitions
Monthly Zoom Meeting
  • Home
  • Library
  • Articles
  • GOODBYE TO 3-D: A Review of Godard’s Goodbye to Language 3D
  • Articles
  • Movie Review Posts

GOODBYE TO 3-D: A Review of Godard’s Goodbye to Language 3D

Randy and Andy February 20, 2015
Godard 3d

A “review” overheard between two attendees of Godard’s 3-D film, “Goodbye to Language 3D.” It went something like this:

It was like “Goodbye to 3D.”
Now why do you say it was “Goodbye to 3-D?”
Because it was like having someone stick their thumb in my eye for 70 minutes. No one could handle 120 minutes of that optical abuse.
It’s a Godard film. It’s French New Wave.
Right. With a total lack of craftsmanship in terms of the 3-D, the photography, the music, the sound. I frankly didn’t know what the story was. The dog was good.
That’s the beauty of it- (the other laughs) it’s, it’s Godard. It’s Godard’s way of telling stories. (other laughs again) Events are off screen. It’s not “what you see is what you get.” Instead it’s what happens around the characters that you experience.
Well I was totally confused by “the story.” A nude couple sitting around reciting Solzhenitsyn, I didn’t understand that.
It’s metaphor. He tells you on the screen in big, red text, “Metaphor.”
Aren’t you the one who overheard someone coming out of the theater saying this was their first 3-D film and they hoped it was their last?
They probably have never seen a Godard film. All they can compare it to are Hollywood movies. For a Godard film this really isn’t that unusual, except for the treatment of the 3-D, which is as unique as anything else he’s ever done.
I don’t think he aligned any of them and the tricks he plays with the cameras is non-traditional-
You’re agreeing with me now.
No. I’m saying, had we made this film, people would think we had no talent and no skills of any kind in filmmaking. And that we fundamentally didn’t understand Stereoscopic 3-D.
He does understand. He chooses to completely ignore and destroy the fundamentals of 3-D.
You think he did that out of total cleverness?
Oh yeah.
The sound was jarring.
He cuts sound just like he cuts the picture. Straight cuts. No mixing and blending. It’s a stylistic choice.
What was with the German guy going around and shooting guns?
That’s the husband.
Oh he was the husband.
Yeah. He was the jilted husband.
Oh I didn’t get that at all. So who did he shoot? Nobody?
He shot the boyfriend.
I just thought he shot in the air.
No.
It’s off screen.
Exactly. He shoots him off screen.
So, was the boyfriend the guy bleeding with his head in the fountain?
Right.
I wasn’t sure. Okay because it’s all non-linear.  I thought he had fallen asleep in the fountain.
It’s all non-linear.
And the dog. Who’s dog was it?
It’s Godard’s dog.
But in the story it’s their dog. It’s their missing dog?
The river carried it away.
I missed that in the story. I guess I nodded off a few times. Like the guy in the fountain. But I was continually jolted wide awake by loud sounds happening suddenly for no reason. Like there’d be black screen for way too long and then some crashing sound and you’d be saying what just happened?
The black gives your eyes a rest from the 3-D.
Yes.
That’s the beauty. He knew that he couldn’t sustain that kind of wild 3-D for that length of time without giving you a rest. And he did it visually with black.
I give him points for being bold but he made every stereoscopic violation possible.
And that’s the beauty of this film.
It attacks your eyes and your ears and your mind.
Fusing 3-D takes place in the mind anyway and he attacks the mind with his type of filmmaking.
There are two signature shots in the film I’ve never seen before where the man and woman are split when the right camera pans away from the left following the man. The left camera remains on the girl. Very French especially since they are nude in the second instance. Another shot looking at a reflection in car window and only one eye you could see through and the other eye was all- aaaaah. (the other laughs) And some shots where the I.O. was so diverged that I saw the background in one eye was completely different than the other eye. So I have to ask, is this bold filmmaking or is it completely idiotic? (the other laughs again) I have to say I think it was a bad movie. But we’re obviously still talking about it, and it was a packed house, and people are buying the Blu-Ray. I’m just saying if we made that movie no one would be buying it. They’re selling this film based on this famous experimental filmmaker.
Well the one guy who can stick his thumb in your eye and be praised for it is Godard. And that’s exactly what he did.
I’m very forgiving when it comes to filmmaking because I know how hard it is. So I give him a “thumbs up” for being a master of getting this film exhibited. But I give it a “thumbs down” for everything technical and story. And I mean the sound, the editing, the stereoscopic 3-D.
And I love it and give it a thumbs up because he destroys all expectation and thumbs his nose at everyone else’s idea of filmmaking. More people need to be as bold and daring.
We got a real optic work out. (the other laughs) People who hate 3-D may like this film as it plays to their prejudices.
For me the fun was trying to figure out what he was manipulating to get the extreme 3-D effects that he achieved. I’ll see it again.
If you’re not ready for the experimental aspect of it you should stay away. I did ask a French Stereographer about it and they said, (affecting a French accent) “I told you zee film is horrible.”

Continue Reading

Previous: February Meeting – 2/19/15
Next: Pasadena Spring Art Night 2015

Related Stories

LA 3-D Club 70th Birthday Party & Awards Dinner – 7/17 Print
  • 3-D Club Events
  • Articles
  • Featured Articles
  • Meetings

LA 3-D Club 70th Birthday Party & Awards Dinner – 7/17

June 30, 2025
June Meeting – 6/19 – SPECIAL EVENT at Velaslavasay Panorama IRS-No2-Panelists
  • 3-D Club Events
  • Articles
  • Meetings

June Meeting – 6/19 – SPECIAL EVENT at Velaslavasay Panorama

June 10, 2025
May 2025 Meeting 5/15 – 5th Competition 300scsc_logo_pair
  • 3-D Club Events
  • Articles
  • Meetings

May 2025 Meeting 5/15 – 5th Competition

May 9, 2025

Join The LA 3-D Club

If you live in the Los Angeles area, or if you simply want to keep up on activities in the global 3-D community, consider joining the LA 3-D Club. Membership includes many 3-D benefits, among them monthly meetings (including five 3-D slide competitions per year), workshops on various 3-D techniques, an annual 3-D equipment auction, 3-D photo exhibitions, subscription to our newsletter, the 3-D News, and unique and stimulating 3-D programs.
CLICK HERE TO JOIN

You may have missed

LA 3-D Club 70th Birthday Party & Awards Dinner – 7/17 Print
  • 3-D Club Events
  • Articles
  • Featured Articles
  • Meetings

LA 3-D Club 70th Birthday Party & Awards Dinner – 7/17

June 30, 2025
June Meeting – 6/19 – SPECIAL EVENT at Velaslavasay Panorama IRS-No2-Panelists
  • 3-D Club Events
  • Articles
  • Meetings

June Meeting – 6/19 – SPECIAL EVENT at Velaslavasay Panorama

June 10, 2025
May 2025 Meeting 5/15 – 5th Competition 300scsc_logo_pair
  • 3-D Club Events
  • Articles
  • Meetings

May 2025 Meeting 5/15 – 5th Competition

May 9, 2025
COMPETITION UPLOADER SCSC Logo_l
  • Articles
  • Meetings

COMPETITION UPLOADER

May 7, 2025

Support The LA 3-D Club

3-D Links

  • 3-D Glossary
  • 3-D Movie List
  • 3-D SPACE – The Center For Stereoscopic Photography, Art, Cinema, and Education
  • Barry & David's Guide To Stereo Photomaker
  • Crossview Tutorial by Barry Rothstein
  • Facebook LA 3-D Club
  • Facebook LA 3-D Club Movie Forum
  • LA 3-D Club Twitter Feed
  • Make 3-D Images From Stereo Pairs With Photoshop
  • Precision Photonics
  • Stereo 3D
  • StereoPhotoMaker and StereoMovieMaker
  • www.stereoscopy.com

LA 3-D Club Members' Site Links

  • 3-D Legends Hall Of Fame Website
  • 3-D SPACE – The Center For Stereoscopic Photography, Art, Cinema, and Education
  • 3D Digital Photo
  • AB3D Creative – Ryan Colditz
  • Barry Rothstein 3D
  • Berezin Stereo Photography Products
  • David Richardson's stereo views of the US Civil War
  • Eric Kurland's 3-DIY blog
  • Franklin Londin – 3Deee Sculptures
  • Jon Schnitzer's THE BRAIN FACTORY BLOG
  • Jon Schnitzer's THE BRAIN FACTORY company
  • Ray '3D' Zone
  • Stephen Les' Amazing 3D Post

About the LA 3-D Club

The LA 3-D Club is a Los Angeles based organization dedicated to promoting the art, enjoyment and science of 3-D imaging. We sponsor photo shows and competitions, how-to workshops, field trips, movie screenings, film festivals and have numerous experienced members available to help those who are interested in creating their own 3-D images.

3-D News Subscription

The LA 3-D Club's monthly newsletter features information and articles of interest to the 3-D photographer, technical information, and reports of activities of the LA 3-D Club. Subscriptions are included with club membership
CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE

Featured Links

  • 3-D Legends Hall Of Fame Website A look back in time to remember some amazing people who enriched our lives. They brought us the marvels of stereoscopic images, equipment, experimentation, techniques and brilliance. Curated by Susan Pinsky. 3-D Legends Hall Of Fame Website A look back in time to remember some amazing people who enriched our lives. They brought us the marvels of stereoscopic images, equipment, experimentation, techniques and brilliance. Curated by Susan Pinsky.
  • 3-D SPACE – The Center For Stereoscopic Photography, Art, Cinema, and Education 3-D nonprofit museum in Los Angeles
  • LA 3-D Club Archive LA 3-D Club Archive
  • LA3DClub Wordpress Login
Copyright © All rights reserved. | MoreNews by AF themes.